Problems with my comment section

Hello,

I love the versitility of this theme. I've been using it a while and two problems, both related to comments, have come up.

First, on the index page, regardless of the number of comments a post has, the number shown is always the same as the first post on the page. For example, a post from yesterday got 10 comments and today's post only has 3. On the index page, yesterday's comment number will say 3.

Also, for some reason, I hit the "Leave a comment" button on the second post on the home page, I get redirected to the first post of the day.

I'm not sure why either of these things are happening, but I'd love to get them fixed.

My blog is Travelin' Local.

Thank you,
Lisa