Using Atahualpa 3.4.6 and latest wordpress 2.9.2.
The is one page, that i cant leave a comment to or reply any comment in it http://www.vocalmixes.net/fckd-up-mind/. Maybe it is bacause i have 3 pages of comments?
Other pages works fine. I ALLOWED comments in this page and in settings, but this option doesnt work anyway. Can you help?

check to see what you have set at dashboard->settings->Discuession->Other Comment Settings-> Automatically close comments on articles older than __ days
then check to see if the comments closed checkbox for the post has been set

Originally Posted by juggledad

check to see what you have set at dashboard->settings->Discuession->Other Comment Settings-> Automatically close comments on articles older than __ days
then check to see if the comments closed checkbox for the post has been set

I have checked! Comments in the page are anabled, and enabled in all settings of wordpress. With the other theme comments were working fine.
Thank you for the reply.

you have something messed up. If I click on page 1 or 2 of the comments, I get a NOT FOUND.
it looks like a permalink issue. The link is

http://www.vocalmixes.net/comment-page-2/#comments

but it should be

http://www.vocalmixes.net/fckd-up-mi...ge-2/#comments

I too have the problem of all my posts showing up as comment closed. I have made sure that comments are enabled on each post, that the comments settings (under discussion settings) are all correct and not closing them down for being too old, then I even switched the comment settings for the theme to enable comments on pages. Nothing seems to work to allow people to comment. Any other thoughts? Thank you so much! You guys are incredibly helpful!

this thread is about comments for a PAGE. Open a new thread and explain what you have done, what versions your using, your URL, weither you have disabled all your pluging and tested basically everthing here: http://forum.bytesforall.com/showthread.php?t=6606