I had been using an older version of Atahualpa and had done a quick edit in the main page HTML to remove single page titles from showing so I could just put my own stuff in there without having to restyle.

Is there an easy way to disable these with the options page?

http://tampamason.com/?page_id=44

You can see whats going on in this page for example.

go to ATO-> Configure SEO
set 'Use Bytes For All SEO options?' to 'yes'
set 'Meta Title Tag format' to 'Page title'

Since I have the All in One SEO plugin active, will turning "Use All Bytes" to Yes in order to set the meta tag title format interfere with it negatively?

EDIT: Seems like it won't work at all since I do have the SEO plug-in active.

have you tried changing the 'Post Title Format' and 'Page Title Format' settings at WP Dashboard->Settings->All in One SEO?

Just tried blanking out both of those options in the SEO pack, no dice.

Even if I disable the plugin the original solution doesn't seem to work.

while using the 'SEO all in one' did you set the 'Use Bytes For All SEO options?' back to 'No'?
I installed the plugin and the suggestion I gave ou worked for me (we are talking about the page title that shows at the top of the browser windor right?)

Oh no, I meant in the actual page itself. Like how at the top it will always show the title of the page. Ie. the About page will have the H1 "About" at the top of the page content.

Is there a way to disable that?

Ahh, that's easy (the toughest thing is understanding the actual issue) you want to remove the headline! That's easy. You just need to add a conditional to test if you are on a PAGE or not.

Go to ATO->Style & edit CENTER COLUMN->The LOOP and find the line

<?php bfa_post_headline('<div class="post-headline">','</div>'); ?>

change it to

<?php if (!is_page()) {bfa_post_headline('<div class="post-headline">','</div>');} ?>

That should do it.

It certainly did. Thank you for the help