I tried disabling all the plugins and I tried toggling between a static page and the blog as the main page. I still have the problem. If I use:
http://privacy.net/?preview=true it works,
http://privacy.net/ it does not. Every other page it works, just the main page is the problem.
edit: I also tried resetting all the theme options and I am getting the same behavior.
edit again: I tried the Wordpress Classic them and the same thing happens there so it looks like it is not related to the theme. I am really confused now.