First, hello and thanks for this great theme.

Here's my problem, which I think is A problem :

Even when I turn off the widget "BFA Popular Posts" on some pages, it's still showing up.

For example, I put "BFA Popular in Cat". So, naturally, I unchecked the box for "BFA PP" for "Category Pages". It won't disappear! Even when EVERY checkbox is cleared!

BTW, totally unrelated, but I noticed you let some spaces in your code that appear in the comment textarea and website.

See ya.

What version of WP and Atahualpa - what's the url?
In a fresh install of WP 2.7.1 abd Atahualpa 3.3.3 this works as you would expect.

Really? Well, then there must be a conflict with one of the plugins I have installed. Anyway, I've added "Widget Logic", and it works this way. It'll do the trick for me. No time to investigate.

I'm using these versions : WP 2.7.1 & Atahualpa 3.3.3, just like you do.
The blog isn't online yet (local server).

BTW, thanks for your help.