There appear to be two different theme layouts, see examples
http://www.airplaycompatible.com
http://www.stmatthewsrandolph.org

How do I make a site look like the airplaycompatible one? It seems random as to which Atahualpa chooses on install

thanks!

There are 5 styles you can use as a starting point in the styles folder. Originally (pre 3.5ish) the classic style is what you got on a new install. That was changed, but so many people had questions when they made changes, that it was changed back to the classic style for a new install, in 3.6.4 (I think)

So you can import any of the styles from the style folder, (they will write over any customization you have done) and use it as a starting point

Try ata-adsense.txt

Juggledad, I've been using this theme for over a year and I never knew that! Thanks!